Reviews Counted: Fresh: 3. Rotten: Critics Consensus: Although it features an inexplicably committed performance from Al Pacino, Jack and Jill is. I have great respect for the man as a comedian and actor. But Jack and Jill is abysmal. The "jokes" are not only bizarrely misplaced - THEY ARE NOT FUNNY. Movie reviews for ' Jack and Jill ' are not good. In fact, they're horrible. Fortunately, many of them are downright hilarious, too. Is this new Adam Sandler comedy a.